Very interesting comment from Jason Schwarz here:
Apple: At Cheapest Level of Steve Jobs Era
I’ve written a few Apple (AAPL) articles in my time but none of them are as
important to your portfolio as this one. Investors dream about finding
obvious disconnects. Widespread misunderstanding leads to huge
opportunity. We have such a scenario developing with Apple.
Although
Apple is the most widely followed stock on Wall Street it is clearly the
most misunderstood. The current perception among traders is that Apple
is expensive because of its 150% rally off of the March 2009 lows.
Seriously, if I polled 1000 traders I believe that 95% of them would
look at the 33 p/e ratio on their screens and tell me that they’d
love to own Apple but it is just too expensive. What they don’t
know, is that the 33 P/E is about to drop significantly and will set up
the opportunity of 2010. Most of us have heard that Apple is about to implement a new
accounting method that will allow them to account for iPhone sales
immediately rather than spread the effect over a 24 month subscription
period. A few analysts here and there have made an attempt to explain
the implications of this change but most simply ignore it. Why?
Because they don’t understand the depth of its impact. I’m
going to simplify the explanation so everyone can understand. On my
first day in college, I’ll never forget my Accounting 101
professor (Norm Nemrow) tell me that the P/E ratio is the single most
important number in the world. This number can make investors very rich
if interpreted correctly. Steve Jobs took over the
company in 1997 and Apple has generated a profit each fiscal year since
2003. Since 2003, Apple has consistently traded at an average P/E ratio
of 32.17 which is consistent with today's current P/E of 33. You can
tell that traders have done their homework and are strict followers of
the P/E valuation.
If you’re like me, you don’t care too
much about current P/E ratios because they are calculated from past
results. The number that really matters is the forward P/E ratio
because it is calculated from future estimated earnings. Well, the
average forward P/E ratio for Apple since 2003 is 22.48. Any guesses
what it is now? Based on the new accounting rules soon to be put in
place, and the 37 billion in cash that Apple has on their books,
Apple’s forward P/E is below 13. This stock has not been priced
this cheaply since Steve Jobs came back to Apple in 1997.
What should Apple stock be priced at according to its
historical P/E norms? Based on expected earnings per share of only
$11.70 in fiscal 2010 (many think earnings per share according to the
new accounting standard will end up closer to $13) the stock should be
priced at $263 today and should reach $376 by September 30, 2010. These
prices do not reflect great years for Apple, they simply reflect the
averages. You want to know what a great year would
look like on September 30, 2010? Let’s use the P/E ratio from
just before the recession began in 2007. With the iPhone added to the
Mac and iPod lines, Apple stock was soaring. Its forward P/E was 28.63
and its current P/E on September 30th 2007 was 39.05.
If we used those
ratios in 2010 it would put Apple stock at $456 by the close of its
fiscal year on September 30th. Making a
comparison between 2007 and 2010 is noteworthy because both are years of
new product releases. On January 9th 2007 Steve Jobs unveiled the first
iPhone and it went on sale June 29th. On January 27th 2010 Steve Jobs
will unveil the Tablet and it should be available sometime in Q2. Both
products are revolutionary but the Tablet arguably is more so because it
will single handedly change the newspaper/magazine/book print industry
as well as the mobile Internet and gaming sectors.
The iPhone was not
nearly as big of a game changer in 2007. Are the future prospects for
Apple better or worse than they were back in 2007? Today Apple has
approximately $40 billion in cash on its balance sheet, it has 3 billion
apps downloaded through the App Store, the iPhone’s international
expansion is just taking off, and of course the Tablet is on its way.
All of a sudden seeing Apple stock at $210 doesn’t seem very
expensive at all. As an investor, I have been
known to take advantage of disconnects. I saw one in oil back in August
2008, I saw one in Bank of America (BAC) back in February 2009; this disconnect in
Apple is bigger than either one of those. Eventually the market will
get it right as it did with oil and BAC. The same thing will happen
with Apple.
3:48:08 PM
|